Friday, December 11, 2009

Story of two Brothers

I learnt this story, perhaps when I was in my 3rd standard.

There were two brothers Ramu and Shyamu. Their Dad in his will had mentioned that all his wealth, which comprised of a coconut tree, a cow and a blanket, will be shared equally by both the brothers after his death. He never really specified what equality was. Shyamu, the intelligent of the two devised an equal sharing algorithm, which stated that the bottom part of coconut tree will be Ramu's property, where as the top part will be his. Similarly the front portion of the cow will be Ramu's and the back portion will be his; and Ramu can use the blanket in the morning- Shyamu will use it in the night.

Ramu respected the brothers decision for sometime, but sooner realized that this algorithm of 'equality' is a flawed one. He negotiated this with Shaymu when the deal finally compromised at - once in a week, Ramu being able to use the blanket during the nights

All this time, while Ramu was buying grass and feeding the cow, Shyamu was making money by selling its milk. In Shyamu's defence, yes- he did some hard work too, in the form of cleaning up the cow shit! While Ramu was manuring the coconut tree, Shyamu was drinking the coconut water. Blanket, let me not speak about it!

Ramu tried once more but then quickly, in his time scale, realized that Shyamu is going to no longer relax his claims on his fathers wealth. The story then takes a different turn. Ramu teaches Shyamu a lesson. But let me modify it a bit here. Teaching lessons donot generally occur in reality. They are just restricted to class rooms or stories. So what happened next was as follows:

Ramu wanted to split with Shyamu, perhaps rightfully claiming whatever he deserved to get. In that unfortunate world, he needed Shyamu's permission to do that. Shyamu, by this time, who was already a lot benefited by Ramus resources, ofcourse did not accept for the split.

Ever since, Ramu continued to fight for a split. But again, Ramu's world was unfortunate. Shyamu never agreed for it. Some people are just born to be on the receiving end of injustice, may be!

My question: Why does Ramu need Shyamu's permission, which is certainly not possible to have, for the split ?

If an ill treated house-wife files for a divorce because she feels her hubby's not treating her well, and more importantly, not letting her work; she better get it. She should not not get it, because husband does not want her to get! Ofcourse, he is concerned about his fat belly thinning down because he needs to cook for himself following the divorce.


I guess, the point is made!

6 comments:

Ragesh said...

well well... what do you know.. you are one among the few :)

Abhishek said...

I get your point. I feel this is a very bad analogy because the actual case that you want to refer to is far more complex. Still, let me try to simplify it in the terms of this post:
If they split the cow, Shyamu won't get the milk (or the dung cakes, considering that is an advantage in villages), and Ramu doesn't get nothing either.
If the tree is split... need I say anything else?
If the blanket is split to six sevenths for Shyamu and one seventh for Ramu, Shyamu will somehow cover himself, while Shyamu will have enough only to wipe his nose because of the cold.
Better ways should be looked out for.

Anonymous said...

gunapaatam!

Berhael said...

Think the demand for a new state is legitimate but don't agree that Hyderabad should be the capital.

Ashtung said...

Since I only have second hand information about it, I cannot really comment on the sharing... But from the outside, I sure as hell think the way it went was undemocratic... Gandhi started holding us (and the British)to ransom through such fasts... Now, even a man who doesn't have majority support can do that... Neither then nor now did the govt. bend because the demand was right... It happened becuse Indian public loves to break in to a riot..

Moreover, you might get a Telangana today, but this will set a precedent where every state will want a split... The greater good of India will be compromised...

aieee college said...

u just said that it is an real world,and then u r saying that women should get divorse without permission of his husband......well in this real world she can do it 4 the money...can't she